by Patrick Bromley
my piece on its director, Joe Lynch, and Holliston) got me thinking about horror sequels that surpass the originals. Not all of you will agree with all of my choices.
1. The Bride of Frankenstein (1935) The accepted wisdom is that James Whale's follow-up to his own Frankenstein isn't just the better movie, it's the best of the Universal monster movies and quite possibly the greatest horror movie ever made. Funny, literate, gothic, subversive and just the right amount of crazy, Bride is a movie that gets better every time you see it. JB and I have talked about the movie's greatness here and here. It basically defines Superior Horror Sequel.
2. Dawn of the Dead (1978) - Sure, all of these are up for debate, but this one is maybe the most subjective choice on the list. If you told me you preferred Night of the Living Dead to its sequel, I wouldn't tell you that you're wrong. For me, though, Dawn isn't just the better movie, it's one of the best horror movies ever made. Everything is bigger -- Romero follows his grim, low-budget, claustrophobic black and white classic with a splashy, colorful, more action-packed sequel that trades realism for brilliant social satire. It just comes down to what you want out of a horror movie. For me, Dawn has everything.
4. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre Part 2 (1986) - Yes, I know I'll probably catch shit for this one. Again, it comes down to personal preference; there's nothing wrong with Tobe Hooper's grimy, brutal original -- I just happen to prefer the demented black comedy of the sequel. It's almost impossible to get a handle on this movie's tone, which is a big part of what is great about it -- the movie finds a completely new way to keep you on edge. Purists and devotees of the first film will likely disagree with this pick, and that's ok. The first movie is great and influential and all. I just think the sequel is better.
5. Final Destination 2 (2003) While I've never been the biggest fan of the Final Destination series -- which plays like Faces of Death for the CW crowd -- I have always found the second entry tremendously entertaining. One-time-great genre director David R. Ellis (of Snakes on a Plane infamy) takes over from James Wong and does two things really right: he stages some incredible set pieces and gives the movie a pitch-black sense of humor without ever making it jokey. The series would continue to vary wildly in quality after this (Ellis is also responsible for the fourth film, the worst in this franchise [and many others]), leaving Final Destination 2 firmly entrenched as the high water mark. Worth watching for the opening crash sequence alone.
7. The Devil's Rejects (2005) Speaking of '70s horror, musician-turned-filmmaker Rob Zombie practically ushered in the movement with the long-delayed House of 1,000 Corpses, an underrated movie that's just now starting to get the credit it deserves. Pretty much everyone agrees, however, that its sequel, The Devil's Rejects, is a superior movie and one of the few horror classics of the new millennium. Brutal, bloody and brilliant.
8. Saw VI (2009) Our relationship with the Saw series is well-documented on this site, as both myself and (especially) Mike have gone to bat for the franchise many times. It's often terrible but never less than fascinating. Only two of the movies can really be called "good" in the traditional sense: Saw III (in its Unrated form) and Saw VI, easily the best of the bunch. It's the only entry that bothers to be about more than what it's about, tackling the current health care dilemma and acknowledging the political context in which it was made, something the other Saw films never managed to do. It's also the only Saw movie in which some of the outcomes are uncertain, giving us a character to (sort of) root for and suspense as to who lives and who dies. It's too bad most of the audience had bailed on the series by part VI.
10. Halloween II (2009) Plenty of people despise Rob Zombie's 2007 remake of Halloween. I don't, but ok, I get it. Plenty of people also despise the 2009 sequel, and that I don't get as much. If you already aren't a Rob Zombie fan, it's not really going to be for you, but if you like his movies then this is VERY MUCH one of them. Better than the first movie in pretty much every way, Zombie's sequel isn't tied down by having to remake anything that came before it -- the movie gets to do its own thing. It can be rough going at times -- it's very violent (and not in a 'fun' way) and at least one performance is pretty shrill -- but it's a horror movie that considers the psychological scars left by the kinds of attacks we see in horror movies. Zombie even makes Michael Myers a character instead of just a shape. All this and a Spirit Horse, too.
Great Article! This is already getting me pumped for scary movie month!ReplyDelete
I want to add one:
28 Weeks Later. It seems like this was overlooked at the time of it's release but I was blown away by this one. I thought it captured everything I liked about the excellent first movie, and expanded on it as most great sequels do. A few images and sequences in this movie really evoke terror, and it is one of the few horror movies that I find "horrifying". The opening sequence (ghost directed by Danny Boyle?) is a work of horror art upon itself and well worth the price of admission. Plus a pre-fame Jeremy Renner is one of the leads.
Oops.. forgot the avatar.ReplyDelete
Nice! Is that who I think it is? Or is it not someone famous...Delete
Yes. Jake Lloyd from Jingle All the Way. His finest acting moment captured forever in avatar form.Delete
Nice! I knew it!Delete
This is so great.Delete
I'm not 100 percent sure but I think that's Jake "now this is podracing" Lloyd, I could be wrong though.ReplyDelete
Back on topic, I actually haven't seen a few of these so I got some work to do. As for the ones I have seen Saw VI is definitely the best Saw (my god I wish they had just stopped there the ending of the movie ends the series, the 7th film is by far the worst in the franchise) Final Destination 2 is definitely the best one although I will admit the last FD movie wasn't too bad and is probably the best one after FD 2. The only place I completely disagree with you is with Friday the 13th part IV. While one of the better sequels my fav in the series was always Jason X (I know it's a small fan club) That movie is such a great black comedy in the vein of Bride of Chucky I can still watch it anytime.
Totally agree on the Final Destination (5nal Destination). And I actually really like Jason X (this happened about a year ago), so you'll get no argument from me.Delete
Your avatar is showing up for me now. Today is a day to celebrate.
I have another one to add that gets shit on A LOT. However, there is more going on than most people give it credit for.ReplyDelete
Blair Witch 2.
In many ways, it was Joe Berlinger's (Paradise Lost 1-3) statement about how he felt the first one mucked with people's perceptions of a documentary.
(Also using the sub heading: Book of Secrets had more to do with Damien, Jesse and Jason than the Blair Witch.)
Artisan altered his director's cut so much that Berlinger calls them out in his commentary on the dvd/cd (an awesome conceit that never took off).
However, I do think what remains is still choice (a word I have not heard used since I visited Chicago in 1986 and that Ferris Bueller gets right).
When the characters realize they were really part of a devil orgy and that they are indeed psychos really impressed this horror fan thirteen years ago.
Awesome article, Patrick - I originally started listening to this podcast (via DVD Verdict) for your great horror movie F'ings - for some reason they're one of my favourite movie things to read about/listen to!ReplyDelete
I whole-heartedly agree with 1,3,5,7 and 9, especially 1 (easily my Universal Monsters favourite) and 7 (holy shit the first time I watched that it got under my skin).
Dawn of the Dead is a tough one for me because I was so blown away by the original NotLD when I watched it for the first time last Scary Movie Month - I think I would agree that DotD is the superior movie in many ways, but I was already so wow'ed by its predecessor that it didn't have the same impact.
6 and 10 I need to see again to have an opinion. I have no memory of Wrong Turn 2 and I remember HATING Halloween 2 (2009) when I watched it. But I try to go into my second viewing of a movie with an open mind because my first impressions aren't always trustworthy, so I'll definitely give it a shot.
I would love to give you shit for Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2 - the original was another one I just watched last Scary Movie Month that really blew me away - but I haven't seen it. I have a hard time imagining it'll top the original, but if you're saying it, I'm certainly open to the possibility!
I refuse to acknowledge Saw - even after all this time the pain is too fresh.
Thanks, Sol. I think there are movies on the list that are objectively "better," like Bride of Frankenstein. But there are also choices that reflect only taste. Dawn of the Dead isn't necessarily a better movie than Night, because George Romero went ahead and made TWO masterpieces. I could even hear an argument for why Day of the Dead is someone's favorite. I might not agree, but I could totally understand it.Delete
TCM Part 2 is an example of the part of my brain that is broken, because I will really respond to things that I shouldn't. It is a crazy mix of tones that's very hard to process on a single viewing -- ESPECIALLY as a sequel to the first movie, because it's such a departure. But I am fascinated and drawn to such movies.
Oh no, oh no, Oh No!ReplyDelete
This article, along with yesterday's Holliston article and having listened to the Movie Crypt's podcast this morning (thanks for that Patrick), I fear Im actually starting to get excited again for Scary Movie Month. Arrghh!
Last years plan was to watch franchises, and with the exception of Saw and Halloween I think I succeeded. I was originally going to do Universal and Hammer this year, but after Junesploitation I think I might be better off going for "The Best". Try to up my quota on quality movies. So articles like this one are greatly appreciated. Thanks again.
Thanks for giving Movie Crypt a shot, Brad. The Kane Hodder episode is really great; he starts choking up at one point telling the story about his burn accident, and it's something. Just promise they won't replace us in your heart.Delete
A lot horror talk lately. I'm starting to get excited, too. Or, at the very least, accepting it as a reality.