by Heath Holland
Heath Holland’s high school nickname was Big Bummer.
Sometimes you know it before a movie even starts. Other times you start to suspect it after a few minutes. Still there are other times when you’re having a blast when the movie you’re watching pulls the floor out from under you, leaving you wondering what happened and if the person next to you will judge you for sobbing uncontrollably. Those tears can mean only one thing: you’ve just watched a big bummer. In the words of the Terminator, “now I know why you cry.”
Here’s a few of my own big bummers. Some of them I enjoy; others not so much. The one superpower they all have in common is the uncanny ability to kill all joy. Mild spoilers for movies that are years old may follow.
The Notebook (2004, dir. Nick Cassavetes)
Kind of like the reverse Magic Mike, this was a movie that seemingly every woman HAD to see about ten years ago. The film sucked audiences in with the promise of steamy romance via Ryan Gosling and Rachel McAdams practically dry-humping in the rain. But then it pulls a bait and switch with septuagenarians James Garner and Gena Rowlands dealing with the reality of mental illness and slowly losing a spouse. Yes, it’s sweet, and the story presented in The Notebook is one that millions of people all over the world have dealt with. So why does this movie leave me with such a bad taste in my mouth and make me feel used and manipulated?
The Wrestler (2008, dir. Darren Aronofsky)
Marley and Me (2008, dir. David Frankel)
Marley and Me is one of those Hollywood films that seems to sell itself: you’ve got a newlywed couple (Owen Wilson and Jennifer Aniston) discovering how challenging life can be when they bring a new puppy into it. Marley is your typical adorable dog, and the film trades on his rascally shenanigans as he and his owners slowly become a family over the years. This film opened on Christmas Day in 2008 and everyone flocked to see it for some yuletide warmth. What no one was expecting was the film to sucker punch them in the stomach by *SPOILERS* having the dog put down in the third act. Now your kids are crying, your wife has makeup running down her face, and you’re thinking about death. Merry Christmas!
Sidebar: A few years ago, I had to have my own dog put to sleep after complications from lymphoma. It was a horrible experience and it totally devastated me. It all happened so quickly and I didn’t really have time to properly say goodbye. On the way home from the veterinarian, I stopped at a big box store because I couldn’t bear the idea of going home and looking at his bed and his food dish. I figured I’d walk around the DVD aisles for a while and try to think about anything except what had just happened. Guess what movie was playing on every single TV screen in the store? Marley and Me. I REALLY don’t like this movie.
Pan’s Labyrinth (2006, dir. Guillermo del Toro)
Up (2009, dir. Pete Docter, Bob Peterson)
I thought Disney Pixar’s Up was going to be a bright and colorful adventure about an old dude in a house carried by colorful balloons. Well, it is…after you get through the crushing montage of a man losing everything that he loves and growing old all alone. WTF?! In order to tell a compelling human story, must we bring the viewer to their absolute lowest point? I mean, anything would have been “up”-lifting after all that mourning. I like this movie, but I think it’s a cheap tactic employed very obviously and deliberately to achieve the desired results. All movies manipulate their viewers, but I don’t like it when it feels as clumsy and blatant as it does here.
The Passion of the Christ (2004, dir. Mel Gibson)
On paper, I was the target audience for this movie when it was released in 2004. Mel Gibson’s depiction of the final days of Jesus, The Passion of the Christ is a marked departure from other religious films such as King of Kings and The Greatest Story Ever Told. Instead of focusing on the life and miracles of Jesus, it focuses on the torture and death (and yes, for about ten seconds, resurrection) in detail never depicted in the New Testament. It’s a horror movie, full of graphic violence and unrelenting brutality, and THIS is what Gibson believes we should be focusing on, instead of all those lessons about forgiveness, humility, and kindness. For the record, I suppose those three things are present in The Passion of the Christ, but it’s hard to see them when they’re buried in so much blood and gore that you can barely look at the screen. Watching this in the theater was exhausting. Everyone was bawling, people were getting up and leaving because they were sick to their stomach, anxiety attacks were happening all over the nation. I once knew a guy who had watched this movie so many times that he would fall asleep with it on at night. Now THAT’S disturbing. For my money, I now think Monty Python’s Life of Brian understands what the gospels are saying better than any biblical movie before it or since. Blessed are the cheesemakers, indeed.
Forrest Gump (1994, dir. Robert Zemeckis)
Patch Adams (1998, dir. Tom Shadyac)
Another Christmas day release, Patch Adams was supposed to be a feel-good movie with Robin Williams returning to comedic form after Good Will Hunting and What Dreams May Come. It did feel good to see Patch Adams as a doctor who set his patients at ease using laughter as his strongest medicine. What didn’t feel good was the subject matter of mental illness, suicide, molestation, and homicide. I recognize that the film is based on the memoirs of the actual Patch Adams, but the movie was marketed as family entertainment. It was Christmas! Ho ho ho, candy canes, reindeer, MURDER. While it was never going to be a masterpiece, truth in advertising and a different release date would have done wonders for this movie.
Those are just a few of my big bummers. Look, I know that not every movie can be sunshine and bubbles and that many of these sad tales of woe (though not all of them) have their place and tell a story that needs to be told. In fact, I’m a big advocate for the downbeat ending, which I don’t think we see enough of in western culture. Still, sometimes a movie can really catch you off guard and break your spirit. When that happens, you remember it for what it was. It’s hard to forget a big bummer.
Great column, Heath. I totally had a similar reaction with my first viewing of Pan's Labyrinth. I've since come to love that movie. It's a weird movie that I can come out of it really optimistic or really cynical depending upon my mood at the time. Sometimes my brain focuses on the whimsy and fantasy so I percieve the ending a certain way; then on other viewings my brain focuses on the horrific wartime brutality and I hate myself for watching it in the first place.ReplyDelete
However, if you want to talk about clumsy and blatant manipulation, you can't go wrong with Bridge to Terabithia.
Though the film that wrecked me the most was an Australian movie called Blessed. The movie shows the interweaving stories of 7 young people wandering the streets at night for various reasons (e.g. running away from home, a break-in gone bad, etc). It then ends with a tease that one of them has died... before replaying the night from the point of view of the mothers... finally, the reveal is that the kids that died were the youngest, most innocent and happy kids out of the whole movie - and they died due to some stupid, random thing. F that movie.
I was warned away from Bridge to Terabithia for being exactly what you said, so I've never seen it. I'm okay with that. And Blessed sounds horrible, too. A lot of my big bummers could have been avoided by some honesty in advertising, but it doesn't sound like that would have helped Blessed, which was going for a sucker punch all along.Delete
I am a big-time dog person, and so am automatically suspicious of any film where a dog is a major character. Call it the "Old Yeller" rule. I am so sick of movies where the poor dog gets killed off in order to teach the human some bullshit lesson about humanity, or whatever.ReplyDelete
I totally agree, but I have also seen two movies in the last month or so that use that device as the jumping off point for their entire narratives: John Wick and Late Phases. So while I'm against it in theory, there do exist exceptions that manage to be good movies and treat that sort of thing with real weight.Delete
I'm with you guys. A movie using animal violence to get cheap heat is one of my biggest pet peeves. It doesn't bother me all the time, especially not when it's tastefully done and adds a layer to the story, like in Riddick, to name just one. So many times, though, it seems like a quick and easy way for a filmmaker to get an easy reaction out of their audience. The most egregious case I can think of right now is in the director's cut of Dances With Wolves, in which Costner chooses to wipe out what seems like a whole zoo's worth of animals to (clumsily) illustrate the hubris of the white man. It's entirely over the top, hamfisted, and unfortunately this 4 hour version is the ONLY cut available on Blu-ray.Delete
They make a joke of this exact subject in "What Just Happened", which is the funniest part of a pretty funny movie IMO.Delete
I couldn't agree more. My mind immediately goes to Turner and Hooch, which is NOT a good movie by any stretch of the imagination, though it does have some amusing moments. And then it does THAT...Completely unnecessary and something that made me go from being ok with wasting about 90 minutes on a disposable film to being truly pissed off.Delete
And the dog killing in the new Evil dead doesn't sit right with me either. Independence day got it right. You can put animals in jeopardy for me but I dont want to see any cruelty or animal death. Come on Boomer !Delete
At least Jack London didn't kill off his animal protagonists. Just their human friends. (Poor Chuck Heston) "The Call of the Wild" and "White Fang"ReplyDelete
Hooray for the Up spanking! That merely okay silent montage everyone drooled over raised all sorts of questions that yanked me out of the movie. Can't they adopt? Didn't they ever travel? If not, why not? Maybe they couldn't afford to because he worked as a balloon-seller his whole life? Hey, guy, what about getting an education and a more challenging/better-paying job, thereby letting you and your wife travel, and creating a job opportunity for a younger person or an immigrant in the process? And don't tell me I shouldn't be asking all these questions because it's all "metaphorical" or some gunk. If you don't want me asking specific questions, don't show me a scene of a specific real-life issue such as medically diagnosed infertility! :PReplyDelete
This has always been my biggest problem with the Notebook. Not only is it soul-crushing, but the last shot is borderline absurd. Almost every girl I've tried to explain this to has come back angrily with "It happens! Look it up!" But I have to admit I make the same argument for the end of Magnolia.ReplyDelete
The all time classic bummer has to be Terms of Endearment, though. Just sayin'.
Speaking of Aronofsky for some reason I don't fully understand yet I really like Pie. I don't know how to articulate why but I really enjoy watching this movie. I do feel it to be a labour of love and that always works for me. I will take a flawed film made from love anyday over any film made as a money making sequel made from cynicismReplyDelete